Current:Home > NewsCan the city of Savannah fine or jail people for leaving guns in unlocked cars? A judge weighs in-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Can the city of Savannah fine or jail people for leaving guns in unlocked cars? A judge weighs in
View Date:2024-12-23 23:25:25
SAVANNAH, Ga. (AP) — A Georgia gun owner’s attorney asked a judge Wednesday to halt enforcement of a Savannah city ordinance that imposes fines and possibly jail time for people who leave guns inside unlocked cars.
The lawsuit by Clarence Belt could ultimately determine whether city officials successfully found a niche where they can legally regulate gun safety in a state where Republican lawmakers have widely abolished restrictions on owning and carrying firearms.
Savannah’s mayor and city council voted unanimously in April to outlaw keeping firearms in unlocked vehicles, with maximum penalties of a $1,000 fine and 30 days in jail. They said the law would make it harder for criminals to steal guns, and cited local police statistics showing more than 200 guns reported stolen last year from vehicles that weren’t locked.
Belt filed suit in May. He lives in Jesup, Georgia, about 66 miles (106 kilometers) southwest of Savannah, but says he frequently visits the coastal city for shopping, eating and doctor appointments. His lawyer, John Monroe, says Belt carries a gun in his vehicle and fears being cited.
“He’s disabled and it’s difficult for him to comply with the ordinance,” said Monroe, who gave no further details about Belt’s disability during a court hearing Wednesday. “He also doesn’t want to comply with the ordinance.”
Chatham County Superior Court Judge Benjamin Karpf didn’t rule Wednesday on Belt’s motion to halt enforcement of the Savannah ordinance while considering his underlying lawsuit that seeks to have it thrown out permanently.
Monroe said Savannah’s ordinance should be voided because it violates a state law prohibiting local governments from regulating “the possession, ownership, transport, (or) carrying” of firearms.
Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr, a Republican, made the same argument in a May letter to Savannah officials stating that “no local ordinance can regulate firearms.” City officials ignored Carr’s warning that they could face civil liability for enforcing the ordinance.
Savannah Mayor Van Johnson, a Democrat and a former police officer, has supported the city’s ordinance as a way to make gun owners act responsibly without infringing on their rights to own or carry firearms.
Bates Lovett, Savannah’s city government attorney, noted in court Wednesday that the state law cited by Belt’s lawyer and Carr doesn’t expressly say local governments can’t regulate gun storage.
Lovett also argued that Savannah’s ordinance isn’t primarily about guns.
“We’re regulating the vehicle, not the firearm,” Lovett told the judge, adding that it’s perfectly legal in Savannah to store a gun in a car. “But once you leave the vehicle, you must lock that vehicle.”
Monroe said Georgia courts have struck down attempts by other local governments to “indirectly” regulate guns, and that any limitations on gun storage by cities should be considered illegal restrictions on possession and ownership.
Savannah police had only issued three citations and one warning for guns left in unlocked cars as of Aug. 15, the Savannah Morning News reported. The police department did not immediately provide an updated total Wednesday to The Associated Press.
Before deciding whether to block Savannah’s gun ordinance, the judge said he first has questions about whether Belt has legal standing to sue the city because he’s not a resident. He gave the lawyers until Sept. 16 to file written briefs on the issue.
Monroe said his client’s residency shouldn’t matter because Savannah’s ordinance applies to residents and visitors. Belt did not attend the court hearing Wednesday.
If Karpf allows Belt’s lawsuit to move forward, the judge predicted a protracted legal battle that could wind through multiple Georgia courts.
“I don’t have any illusion about having the final word on this,” Karpf said.
veryGood! (3)
Related
- 'Cowboy Carter' collaborators to be first country artists to perform at Rolling Loud
- US men's basketball looks to find 'another level' for Paris Olympics opener
- Allegations left US fencers pitted against each other weeks before the Olympics
- Watching the Eras Tour for free, thousands of Swifties 'Taylor-gate' in Munich, Germany
- Nicole Scherzinger receives support from 'The View' hosts after election post controversy
- Waffle fry farewell? Chick-fil-A responds to rumors that it's replacing its famous fries
- 1 killed in Maryland mall shooting in food court area
- Peyton Manning, Kelly Clarkson should have been benched as opening ceremony co-hosts
- Paraguay vs. Argentina live updates: Watch Messi play World Cup qualifying match tonight
- Celine Dion saves a wet 'n wild Paris Olympics opening ceremony: Review
Ranking
- Diamond Sports Group can emerge out of bankruptcy after having reorganization plan approved
- Real Housewives of New Jersey Star Melissa Gorga’s Hacks for Stress-Free Summer Hosting Start at $6.49
- 1 killed in Maryland mall shooting in food court area
- Judge denies bid to move trial of ex-officer out of Philadelphia due to coverage, protests
- Utah AD Mark Harlan fined $40,000 for ripping referees and the Big 12 after loss to BYU
- How Olympic Gymnast Suni Lee Combats Self-Doubt
- Joe Biden is out and Kamala Harris is in. Disenchanted voters are taking a new look at their choices
- California Still Has No Plan to Phase Out Oil Refineries
Recommendation
-
Jessica Simpson’s Sister Ashlee Simpson Addresses Eric Johnson Breakup Speculation
-
Should Companies Get Paid When Governments Phase Out Fossil Fuels? They Already Are
-
Andy Murray pulls off unbelievable Olympic doubles comeback with Dan Evans
-
Who plays Deadpool, Wolverine and Ladypool in 'Deadpool and Wolverine'? See full cast
-
2025 NFL mock draft: QBs Shedeur Sanders, Cam Ward crack top five
-
Nevada attorney general appeals to state high court in effort to revive fake electors case
-
Team USA men's water polo team went abroad to get better. Will it show at Paris Olympics?
-
Three members of family gospel group The Nelons killed in Wyoming plane crash